The Problem of Evil in Plotinus – B. A. G. Fuller ( PDF 1912)

The Problem of Evil in Plotinus – B. A. G. Fuller (1912)

The Problem of Evil in Plotinus
The Problem of Evil in Plotinus 


 A classic 1912 philosophical study exploring Plotinus’s famous Neoplatonist account of evil. Fuller unpacks Plotinus’s difficult question: If the One / the source of everything is perfect Good, how can evil exist in the world? He walks through Plotinus’s theory of emanation, the three layers of evil — metaphysical, physical, and moral — and the controversial idea of matter as the seat of evil, while also pointing out tensions and contradictions inside Plotinus’s system. This is an advanced‑level academic work, perfect for readers already familiar with Neoplatonism. 

Fuller’s reading is one scholar’s interpretation; other philosophers and historians read Plotinus differently.


Fuller’s core argument from the excerpt:

 Trying to pin down a neat, strict definition of evil has historically helped very little when tackling the deeper philosophical problem of evil. Most philosophers simply accept evil as an obvious given, without carefully untangling all the different things we label “evil”: sin, imperfection, pain, suffering, disappointment, failure, crime, even physical sickness such as colic. These things seem totally unrelated on the surface, yet we lump them all together under the single word “evil”.
 
 Fuller explains the real question is NOT sorting and classifying every type of bad thing in the world. The bigger metaphysical question is: what does the existence of evil mean for reality as a whole? For clarity, he uses the classic Leibniz‑inspired three‑part split: metaphysical evil, physical evil, moral evil; and notes you could also add a fourth category for unfairness — when people’s rewards do not match what they deserve. He clarifies he is using “metaphysical evil” in his own specific way: the inherent dissatisfaction with finitude itself — the idea that the finite, limited nature of our world is seen as imperfect, before you even judge the good or bad experiences inside it. This is a common perspective found within mystical and Neoplatonic thinking.

Who is Plotinus


Plotinus (c. 204/205 – 270 CE) — born in Roman Egypt, taught in Rome; widely known as the founder of Neoplatonism (a label given by later scholars; Plotinus thought of himself simply as a follower of Plato). His writings were collected and arranged by his student Porphyry into The Enneads — six groups of nine treatises each.
 

🧠 His Core Metaphysics (3 Hypostases)

 
The One / The Good — the ultimate, indescribable, perfect source of everything, beyond being and thought
Intellect (Nous) — the first emanation from The One; home of Plato’s eternal Forms
Soul (Psyche) — emanates from Intellect; gives life and order to the physical, material world
 
💡 Emanation: The One “overflows” without being diminished, flowing downwards through Intellect → Soul → Matter. The further from The One, the greater the limitation, imperfection, and potential for evil.
 
😈 Plotinus on Evil (exactly what Fuller’s 1912 book is about!)
 
- Evil is NOT an independent, equal power fighting against The Good
- Evil is privation / lack / falling‑away from the Good
- Matter (the lowest level of reality) is the primary site of evil’s possibility: formlessness, disorder, limitation
- Human evil comes when the soul turns toward the material, bodily side instead of upward toward Intellect and The One
- This is exactly the framework Fuller examines in The Problem of Evil in Plotinus, splitting evil into metaphysical / physical / moral evil
 
📜 His Influence
 
His work deeply shaped Christian, Jewish, Islamic, and medieval / Renaissance philosophy, mysticism, and theology for centuries after his death.

Download The Problem of Evil in Plotinus – B. A. G. Fuller (1912) from Internet Archive
Adel Alsherif

​In Cairo, I watched English books get thrown into wealthy neighborhoods' rubbish bins—only to be salvaged by booksellers who couldn’t read a word of them, resold, and overpriced based on how desperately students needed them. Meanwhile, modern shops dominated search results, slapping fresh covers on public-domain classics to charge steep prices. I created StudyEbooks to break that cycle entirely: free, direct PDFs making knowledge accessible to everyone, with no subscriptions or hidden costs.

Previous Post Next Post